Heading into the 2024-25 NHL season, the Tampa Bay Lightning find themselves in a transitional phase, and it’s one that could either propel them back to Stanley Cup contention or signal the beginning of a prolonged retool. The most glaring change is the departure of Steven Stamkos, the longtime captain and face of the franchise, who left in free agency. While the loss of Stamkos is significant, the addition of Jake Guentzel, a proven goal scorer, gives the Lightning a strong offensive replacement, but it raises questions about chemistry and leadership on and off the ice.
The return of Ryan McDonagh strengthens a blue line that was one of the weaker points for Tampa last season, especially at even strength. McDonagh’s veteran presence and defensive acumen could be just what the Lightning need to shore up their defensive deficiencies, especially after finishing 22nd in the league in goals allowed per game last year. This move, coupled with the continued rise of young defenseman Darren Raddysh, offers promise for a more balanced defensive effort, especially with Victor Hedman still anchoring the top pairing.
However, questions remain about the team’s depth scoring. Beyond stars like Nikita Kucherov and Brayden Point, there’s a need for more offensive contribution from the supporting cast. The Lightning’s power play was elite last season, but their five-on-five production was alarmingly mediocre, ranking in the bottom half of the league. Can players like Guentzel, Cam Atkinson, and Zemgus Girgensons fill the void left by Stamkos and others, or are we looking at a top-heavy team overly reliant on its stars?
One of the most intriguing aspects of the Lightning’s season will be how their retooled roster can perform in a competitive Atlantic Division. With teams like the Toronto Maple Leafs and Florida Panthers expected to contend, Tampa Bay’s ability to blend their old guard with new faces will be tested. Are they simply shuffling deck chairs, or is this a genuine attempt to re-open their championship window? Either way, the Lightning’s performance in the first half of the season will likely define their long-term trajectory.
It’s a fascinating moment for Lightning fans. Will this be a season of resurgence or the start of a rebuild?
